|
Home / Finance / Stock Market Investing
The Squeeze-Out or Buying out a Minority Interest Shareholder at an Unfair Price
By:Dave Kauppi
If you are a minority interest shareholder in a privately held company, watch out for these Red Flags:
· The majority shareholder grants himself a salary and benefit package way above the going market rate – in effect granting him a constructive dividend
· No dividends are paid from a very profitable company
· He begins using the company as his personal piggy bank
· You are removed from your Board of Director position
· Company financial information is withheld from you
· You are fired from the company without cause
If one or of these events has occurred, watch out! The next shoe to fall is an unsolicited offer to buy out your shares. The offer price seems unusually low. If you protest, expect the buyer to refer you to the shareholder agreement where the corporation has the right of first refusal to buy your shares at net book value. That number, for most companies, values your shares at pennies on the dollar.
You next get the speech that the majority shareholder will never sell his company. The price I am offering is all the company can afford. We are not going to pay any dividends. This is a risky market and the business could falter. This is the only way you are going to get any liquidity for your stock.
In family situations this can be devastating. It is usually the result of children inheriting the business through either gifting or from dad’s estate. Because 90% of his net worth is tied up in the business, to be fair, he has to give essentially equal shares to all of his children. Maybe Son A and Daughter C work in the business and Son B and Daughter D do not. Dad gives 30% ownership to each sibling in the business and 20% to each sibling that is not involved.
The two siblings running the business begin to blur the lines between stock ownership and employment. They develop an attitude of entitlement. Those other two siblings did nothing to grow this business. The company-involved owners begin to view their stock as more valuable than the other siblings. Their salaries and perks get bloated and no dividends get paid to the other shareholders. I don’t think Bill Gates refuses to pay dividends to his stockholders because “they did nothing to grow this business”.
Here is where the problems begin. Dad has left a company shareholder agreement in place that makes it almost impossible for a minority shareholder to get a fair price for their company stock. Dad has also done a great job of estate tax planning, using all available legal means to minimize the gift and estate taxes resulting from transferring ownership to the next generation.
The most common approach is to form two or more Family LLC's that would be the owners of the company stock and then dad gives a gift of an equal share of the LLC's to each heir. This effectively breaks the company into several minority interest ownership positions. Now a qualified valuation firm is hired to value the LLC’s. All of a sudden the value of the company evaporates.
Here is how it works. Let’s say that Johnson Corporation would command a price of $9 million if an M&A firm in a competitive market transaction sold it. However, Johnson Corporation is 33% minority owned by three different Family LLC’s. The valuation firm values the company stock held in each LLC not at $3 million, but at $3 million less a 40% lack of control discount, or $1.8 million. Next they apply a lack of marketability discount (after all, the shareholder agreement restricts the sale to outside investors) and the valuation drops further to $1,080,000. Now the three LLC’s are added back together and the $9 million company is valued at $2,240,000 for “Gift and Estate Tax Purposes”.
This document is submitted as supporting documentation with the gift or estate tax filing – very official. The IRS examiner reviews it and accepts it as the basis for the tax payment. Two years later the two siblings running the company approach the other two siblings and present them with a buy-out offer accompanied with this valuation that was filed and accepted by the IRS. Son B owns 20% of the company stock through his interests in the three Family LLC’s. He is offered 20% of $3,240,000 or $648,000 for his company ownership. The fair value is 20% of $9,000,000 or $1,800,000.
He has no idea what the company is worth and has never been given any information of earnings or comparable M&A transactions in the market. Even though the valuation has on its cover, “For Gift and Estate Tax Purposes Only,” he does not understand the implications of that standard blanket disclaimer.
His natural reaction is that this document was filed with the IRS and accepted. It must be pretty close to what my stock is worth. If someone were not involved in this area of law professionally (estate tax attorney, estate planner, tax accountant, valuation firm, investment banker, or IRS agent), they would likely accept this as the accurate value of their shares. I tell clients that it would be like being handed an MRI of my heart and being asked to interpret it. I am not experienced in this very specialized area and therefore would depend on my doctor to interpret it for me.
A nationally recognized and credentialed valuation firm complete with 50 pages of discounted cash flow and other sophisticated analysis and data completed this valuation. It next passed the scrutiny of the IRS examiners. Now a family member is interpreting it for you. What conclusion are your supposed to draw?
Unfortunately this happens all the time. Usually it results in the non-involved siblings having a standard of living that is significantly different than what dad had intended when he equally divided his estate among all his children. Dad would not approve.
Digg
del.icio.us
Blink
Stumble
Spurl
Reddit
Netscape
Furl
Article keywords: Squeeze-Out, shareholder oppression, minority shareholder rights, minority interest valuation
Article Source: http://www.articles2k.com
Dave Kauppi is a business broker and President of MidMarket Capital. We help business owners with all aspects of Mergers and Acquisitions.
|
|
| Top Stock Market Investing Articles |
- 1). In Value Stock Investing, Quality is Job One By : Steve Selengut
How much financial bloodshed is necessary before we realize that there is no safe and easy shortcut to investment success? When do we learn that most of our mistakes involve greed, fear, or unrealistic expectations about what we own? Eventually, successful investors begin to allocate assets in a goal directed manner by adopting a realistic Investment Strategy.
|
- 2). Openwave-Could the little company ever become king? By : J Randy Durig
Openwave has a very unique and valuable business in the wireless data market. It has a dominate market share of 50% in both the browser and in the gateway transitions for mobile phones. Both products are a core element in the data cell phone market.
Our philosophy is to own the critical elements in markets that appear to have revolutionary growth. In January 2004 we wrote an article saying the wireless revolution has begun.
|
- 3). Stocks -A Winning Way To Scan For Stocks That Are In Uptrends By : Peter Lim
With thousands of stocks listed in the stock exchange for trading, how does a trader go about his stock selection? I am not refering to the fundamental approach where the trader studies the fundamentals of the company, and research the performance results of the company, check its price-earnings ratios or check its balance sheets and turnover and its dividend yield.
|
- 4). Stock Trading Psychology By : Tim Renolds
Many of today’s highly successful traders will tell you that the general key to success in trading is to be able to comfortably take a loss. It is general knowledge among experts in the trading psychology field and among traders that the market is not predictable and it is safe to say that it never will be. In the world of trading, it is expected to take a loss; even those who are highly skilled traders know that it is inevitable.
|
- 5). How to make money in the stock market By : Alexander Chong
There are abundant of money in the stock market. However, not everybody can get the money out from there. Some people can gain a lot from the stock market but some has lost a lot of money there. It is very indecisive. Sometime at that moment, you loss money but after a few days, you may earn a profit and sometime is reverse. So, how should we do to get the money out from the stock market? Usually, there are two ways to get the money out from the stock market; that are investing and trading.
|
- 6). Stock Brokers -- Just The Facts By : Ron King
Most of the buying and selling on the stock market is handled by stock brokers on behalf of their clients, who are the investors. Many different types of brokerage services are available.
Full-Service Brokers
"Full-service brokers" offer a variety of ways to help clients meet their investment goals. These brokers can give advice about which stocks to buy and sell, and often have large research departments that analyze market trends and predict stock movements, for their clients.
|
- 7). Entities in the trading system in Indian Stock Markets By : deepan
There are four entities in the trading system. Trading members, clearing members, professional
clearing members and participants.
1. Trading members: Trading members are members of NSE. They can trade either on their own
account or on behalf of their clients including participants. The exchange assigns a Trading member
ID to each trading member. Each trading member can have more than one user.
|
- 8). Use the Power of Autosuggestion in the Stock Market By : Trading Framework
Self-Confidence is an essential starting point for any business venture. This is true even more if the business is trading in the stock market because psychology plays such a major role. Keep reading, this might change your life!
About 10 years ago, I received a copy of the book "Think and Grow Rich!" written by Napoleon Hill. Today, I credit most of my success in business (including trading) to this book.
|
|
|
- 10). Stock Trading – What Every Investor Should Know By : panikkarson
Never try to fight against a trend.
It may be tempting to buy a falling stock in order to average your costs. In fact, many investors seem to recommend such a step. In practice, in a majority of situations this only results in throwing good money after bad.
Always have a stop loss, for every stock. If your stock moves down, at what price must you definitely sell? If you do not use historical data and technical analysis to arrive at investment decisions, you must have at least a fixed-amount method.
|
| New Stock Market Investing Articles |
|
|
|
|
- 3). The China Factor By : George Leong
Unless you have been in a cocoon, you most likely are aware that China will in all probability become the next economic superpower in the world. The country’s economy is on steroids, growing at close to double digits over the past few years and this is not expected to change.
And if you understand the vast size of the country’s economic engine, you would also understand that China is a place where you need to have some capital invested.
|
- 4). Six Keys to Find Momentum Stocks By : Billy Williams
Copyright 2006 Billy Williams
Momentum stock trading has been around for awhile and has been proven to a sound method for creating incredible wealth in the stock market. During the 1990s, for example, Clear Channel Communications went up 5,615%, Emulex rose 6,412%, Dell Computer went up 10,198%, Activision went up 13,819%, and Semtech rose 15,231%.
|
- 5). An Industry Blueprint To Stocks And Shares By : P. Johnson
In this day and age, a lot of things have changed from how they used to be, which can be new and exciting for most.
Because of the large size of the stock market, beginner investors appear to feel overwhelmed as to where to even activate investing their money. To most people, the stock market presents a messy web of options but does not reveal the highway map of clarity to guide their way along way in their investment adventure.
|
- 6). Buy To Cover Orders With Stock Trading By : P. Johnson
If you have always wanted to know more about this topic, then get ready because we have all the information you can handle.
Within the buy to cover orders, there are four options in which to place against your stock purchases. When you buy to cover on a stock order, you are in agreement that you will buy the stock at the latest share price; however, because there is a lag between the time you approve to buy the stock and the actual transaction, a price difference may occur.
|
- 7). Stocks And Shares - How To Trade Profitably In A Bear Market By : Peter Lim
Trading in a bull market is easier than trading in a bear market. Many traders find they can make money trading in bullish markets, but when there is a major correction underway or when the market is bearish, they literally freeze and are unable to trade successfully or find profits in their trading.
First,when a market has collapsed, it is important to accept the fact that the market trend has changed from bullish to bearish.
|
- 8). Constant Access with Stock Trading Online By : Manny St Cyr
In a world built on capital, we humans are forever vying for that next big money-maker. It seems that everybody forever desires more cash. Some strive for a senior education; others compete for that big promotion. No worry what the method, we all find a way of increasing our income. Investing is a customary form of making an added buck. With the obsession of the stock market in gorged affect, many of us chance on that up-and-coming business, or upright product that has the latent to fuel in value.
|
- 9). Vonage Shorts Out, Under Armour Has Lofty Ambitions By : George Leong
Under Armour, Inc. (UAI) debuted on November 18, 2005 at $31. The maker of branded performance clothing is growing its brand recognition via the use of hip brand promotion that is trying to wrestle away interest from the traditional buyers of Nike (NKE).
Under Armour has targeted the youth and athletic market where it competing with the established and strong Nike brand.
|
- 10). Online Stock Trading By : Kent Pinkerton
Among the many revolutionary changes brought about by the advent of the Internet is online stock trading. Once the exclusive preserve of the rich and the wealthy, the stock market has now become a place where even the common man can play a part. Investors today can use Internet client-server technology to trade stocks anywhere, anytime they like. Just a couple of mouse clicks and the client is through with a thousand-dollar transaction!
There are several ways in which one can participate in online stock trading.
|
|
|
