|
Home / Personal Development
Exploring Mechanisms You Developed to Survive Your Family - Rebellion
By:Irwin Gootnick
You developed mechanisms of accommodation, rebellion, and mimicry to survive growing up in your family. Let’s look at rebellion. What’s another way of saying rebellion? Refusal to comply with parental demands or needs and the restrictions they impose. Yes, it’s true that a certain amount of rebellion is normal and healthy in the development of a child’s independence and control. But once again, when a parent’s expectations are extreme, that child will rebel against accommodating his or her parents in order to fight their attempts to limit the normal goals we set for ourselves.
Children aren’t usually able to complain to their parents about how their parents’ specific behavior is spoiling their life. When was the last time you heard a young daughter complaining to her father, “Dad, your behavior is ruining my psychosocial development.” Right: never. So, rebellion, as a protest, is meant to signal, or communicate, to parents that their actions are not just distressing, but they need to stop—period. And that would be fine if not for one problem: Parents have their own hidden self-defeating motivations from their own childhoods. Do these cause them to keep behaving badly? You bet it does. Does it also prevent them from receiving their child’s message in a mature way? Right again. Ultimately, parents’ unresolved childhood issues wind up provoking them even more and the cycle of parent/child conflict continues unchanged. Let’s look at another case study. It’s the real-life story of Will, a stubborn man who used rebellion as a way of acting out against his parents’ demands.
WILL
Will was looking for more control. He was a wealthy businessman who refused almost all requests made of him by his wife, Tracy. Any time Tracy asked for, suggested, or requested something, Will’s response was always the same, “No!” Whether her suggestion was important or meaningless, Will’s negative response never wavered. Why did he do this, despite the fact that he was really provoking Tracy? Because Will was rebelling against his strong impulses to accommodate others. A devastating combination of parental traits created in Will a strong inclination towards giving in to others. Let’s look at his father first.
Authoritarian and pompous, he required Will to accept his point of view and to give in to his orders, and if Will didn’t, his father would react angrily. Comments like, “What’s wrong with you?” “Why are you so thick headed?” “Listen to me, I have years of experience and I know what I’m talking about,” dominated Will’s childhood. Will’s father needed to be completely in charge, and although Will viewed that as a sign of weakness, he still complied with the needs of his father to maintain his father’s position of authority and self-importance. He did this by agreeing with and doing whatever his father expected of him.
Now, for his mother, Will was a confidant and companion. Because her husband was uninterested in her (which she confided to Will), Will felt obliged to cheer her up and spend time with her. He did this so she wouldn’t feel lonely or unhappy. Pressure from both parents left Will unable to do what made him happy. If he did, he felt he’d hurt his parents because he wasn’t focusing on their needs. And so, Will grew up feeling that his role was to accommodate everyone else’s wants.
To make himself feel that he was more in control of his life (and not be the wimp who complied with everyone else’s demands), Will, without even being aware of it, developed a protective, stubborn quality of automatically saying no to people’s wishes, even if they seemed reasonable. This was the opposite of Alex’s way of accommodating everyone.
Will complained, when he came to see me, that he and his wife fought all the time. He said he couldn’t stand Tracy because she was too demanding and critical of him. Will had no awareness that his lifelong inclination to give in to people, which we now know started back with his parents, was behind his problem with Tracy. Any request from her was viewed as dangerous because he (unconsciously) worried about having to submit to her and become her servant. And the problem wasn’t just confined to his marriage, either. Every relationship caused him anxiety about having to become a slave to the other person’s requests.
Becoming more aware of the source of his problem, Will began realizing that he equated reasonable requests with the unpleasant demands of his parents. Therefore, he wasn’t able to rationally evaluate his wife’s requests and suggestions. Will gained understanding of his problem, and the effect was an increasing relative comfort with saying no to Tracy when he meant it and saying yes when that was the appropriate response.
Soon they began fighting less. Disagreements now took on new meaning for Will. They no longer served only the purpose of fighting against giving in. Now they could also reflect his actual point of view.
NO RELIEF
When children fight against excessively accommodating the flaws of their parents and siblings, they suffer so much guilt for their rebellion that they resume accommodating in order to relieve their guilt. Where does that leave them? Shifting back and forth between two evils and never finding relief.
Digg
del.icio.us
Blink
Stumble
Spurl
Reddit
Netscape
Furl
Article keywords: Gootnick, Rebel, Accommodation, Family, Survive, Mechanism, Develop
Article Source: http://www.articles2k.com
Excerpted from Self-Help for Smarties: Secret Success Codes for Weight Loss, Love, Career and Parenting by Irwin Gootnick, M.D. (Penmarin Books, May 2006).
|
|
| Top Personal Development Articles |
- 1). What To Do When Your Fears And Worries Overwhelm You By : Stan Popovich
What do you do when your worries and anxieties overwhelm you? Here is a brief list of techniques that a person can use to help manage their worries and anxieties.
Sometimes what we fear may happen can be overly exaggerated. A lot of times, our worrying can make the problem even worse. Remember that all the worrying in the world will not change anything.
|
- 2). Stuttering And Stammering Speech Impediment By : blueboy
Stammering or as it is sometimes known as stuttering is a form of speech impediment.
My name is Stephen Hill and I had a stammer for eighteen years. I went to various types of speech therapy which even though was of some use, never really offered me any hope of a "cure".
At the age of twenty two, after a lot of hard work I managed to overcome the stammer and I now help other people to achieve fluency.
|
- 3). The first 14 dominant laws of the subconscious mind By : Emmanuel Segui
Copyright 2006 Emmanuel Segui
The subconscious mind is fascinating and intriguing. Yet, it is challenging to understand how it works so you can use its full power solve our problems and enhance every aspect of your life.
Here are the difficult principles of the subconscious mind made very easy so you can apply them in your life today and see results tomorrow.
|
- 4). Stop Fear Now By : Denton Krypps
I'm convinced that fear is one of the worst things in life. Think about all of the negative ways that fear affects your life. Think about all of the decisions you make or do not make because of fear in your life. Or think about the risks that you do not take or the relationships you do not pursue because of fear. You would do well to take a good look at the fears in your life and to attempt to tackle them head first until they are no longer fears.
|
|
|
- 6). Avoiding Your Persistent Fears Will Not Make Them Go Away By : Stan Popovich
Your fears, anxieties, and other problems have the best of you and you don’t know where to turn for help. At some point you feel totally helpless as you struggle each day. What do you do?
As a layman and an author of a Managing Fear book, there were times that my fears had the best of me. Through these experiences, there is one thing that I learned.
|
- 7). Success After Failure - Even Genghis Khan Lost Some Early Battles By : John Watson
Both the worst and the best of the great achievers had the belief in themselves and the resilience to overcome early failures. One of these was none other than Genghis Khan. There are powerful lessons we can learn from him.
In 1162 a child, called Temujin, was born in Mongolia clutching a blood clot - a sign that he was destined to be a great warrior.
|
- 8). Crisis Management: The Most Basic Of Needs By : Sandy Baker
Crisis management is something that every individual needs to consider. Whether you are preparing yourself for a crisis situation or if you are responsible for a school full of children, it is necessary to be prepared. There are excellent resources to help you do this and it also helps to take a good look at your individual situation. There are many types of crisis management situations and we will discuss that here.
|
- 9). Being the Mountain By : Judy Ringer
As I hiked up the path to the Peaceful Valley Chapel, I relished the quiet of my early morning solitude. After many years as a participant and assistant instructor at Thomas Crum's Journey To Center Program, this beautiful and energizing ten-minute hike had become a personal ritual. Each morning of each Journey to Center week, before our breathing and meditation session at 7, I always hike to the top of this small mountain to be inspired by the view of a much higher mountain range in the distance.
|
- 10). What Causes People To Develop A Speech Impediment? By : blueboy
I am one of many people who are unfortunate enough to develop a speech impediment in childhood. This article describes why these impediments may occur and how I went about achieving fluency. For the purpose of this article, I concentrate on the speech impediment known as stuttering.
There are many reasons why people may develop a stutter, it can be.
|
| New Personal Development Articles |
- 1). Achieve Emotional Freedom By : ian Williamson
Emotional Freedom Techniques, or EFT as it is most commonly known, is probably the most popular of a group of techniques collectively referred to as Energy Psychology (EP)
|
|
|
- 3). Are You Really Making Decisions? By : Garry Zancanaro
There is a massive difference between hoping and wishing for success, happiness, self improvement, or that something will change in our lives, and actively deciding to make changes to our lives.
|
- 4). Why Self Improvement Is Important - Part 1 By : Garry Zancanaro
An alarming percentage of people spend most of what they earn and many also have large debts. They are often no more that a few paydays away from bankruptcy and have little, if anything, put aside for emergencies, much less for a comfortable retirement.
|
|
|
- 6). Dealing With Frustration By : Garry Zancanaro
We all suffer from frustration, and being able to effectively deal with frustration is a very important skill to develop. It can be a decisive factor between success and failure.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
- 10). To Move Forward You Have To Be Able To Bounce Back! By : Garry Zancanaro
Successful people are also disappointed and affected by setbacks, and certainly get knocked down more often than most, if only because they try more things. This may happen not once or twice, but dozens or even hundreds of times. But successful people refuse to stay down - because they are resilient and will not be denied their dreams and goals.
|
|
|
