Seller Earn Outs in Business Sales – A Business Broker View

By:Dave Kauppi

Contrary to what many sellers believe, an earn out component to a business sale is not necessarily a bad thing. As a business broker firm, we see the incidents of bad buyer behavior, but if properly used an earn out can be an excellent tool to maximize seller proceeds. First rule of earn outs – if you do not trust the buyer, there is not enough contractual language available to protect you. I will go one further. If you do not trust the buyer, do not do any kind of deal with him.

If you are negotiating the sale of your business, you want an earn out to be structured so that if the guy you negotiated with and was the deal champion gets “hit by a truck’ his replacement can not interpret the agreement to your detriment. If you can, you want to have your earn out based on top line sales as opposed to division profits, for example. It is amazing how an overhead allocation from corporate can wipe out your division’s earnings.

So once you have your earn out based on top line revenue are you safe? What if your company’s product were added to the acquirer’s suite or products? What if your product were used as a loss leader to help sell the other products? Just like that, your earn out revenue disappears. The way to protect yourself is to establish a minimum sales price for your product for purposes of your earn out calculation. You don’t want to try to dictate pricing to the new owner. You simply want to be given fair credit for the revenues that would have resulted had your product sold at historical levels.

In spite of the risks, however, there are many reasons a seller would want to employ an earn out to maximize his business valuation. Here are a few:

1. The seller has several big deals in the sales pipeline and wants to get paid for them. The buyer is going to heavily discount those forecasted deals if he is backed into an all cash at close structure. If the seller is willing to share the risk for those deals closing with an earn out component tied to the deals, the buyer will be much more generous. If the deals don’t close, it costs the buyer nothing. If they do close, he is happy to write you the earn out check.

2. The seller anticipates that product sales will explode once the buying company integrates it with their distribution network. If the seller does not have strong sales or profits, but has a great product, it will be difficult to get the optimal selling price using historical sales and profit figures. Rather than take a low price based on those numbers, it may be better to bet on future performance and base a major component of transaction value on sales generated by the much larger company. Receiving 20% of a 10 times greater sales number as an earn out is a big win for the seller.

3. An earn out can help bridge the value gap between buyer and seller and be the needed catalyst to getting the deal completed.

The use of an earn out can be appropriate as a way for a seller to maximize his sales proceeds in the right circumstances. Just remember that the buyer champion that has established a relationship with you and is compelled to honor the intent of the earn out agreement will most likely be transferred or promoted before your earn out term is completed. You now are in the position of having this agreement interpreted by a person who has no connection or loyalty or knowledge of the intent or the agreement. His mode will be to interpret the agreement in a way to “minimize the expense of the future payment.” Just make sure that interpretation cannot destroy the economics of the deal you originally negotiated.

Digg del.icio.us Blink Stumble Spurl Reddit Netscape Furl

Article keywords: seller earn out, business broker Chicago Illinois, merger acquisition, sell technology company

Article Source: http://www.articles2k.com

Dave Kauppi is a business broker and President of MidMarket Capital. We help business owners with all aspects of Mergers and Acquisitions.

Top Sales Articles
1). Why Use Lead Management Software? By : Halstatt Pires Having a popular website, or popular company of any type, is entirely dependant on sales. Effective sales at that. Maintaining a healthy profit is key to the long-term survival of your web site or business and this means knowing the difference between your effective sales leads and your ineffective sales leads. Small Business Owner Lead management software is perfect for the small business owner or webmaster of a website.
2). Power Words By : Wendy Weiss I conducted a teleconference a few weeks ago with people who were new in sales and new to prospecting. The focus of the call was to help participants get beyond fear and understand their prospecting process. One of the participants on the call told me that she had been given the telephone prospecting script that her team leader uses to set appointments.
3). Secrets to Getting Paid for Your Creative Ideas and Proposals By : Kirstin Carey Many creative professionals such as event planners, interior designers, and decorative painters are frustrated when potential clients steal their ideas and take them to cheaper companies. They present their ideas in a proposal or presentation and later find that they didn’t get the client and their designs are being used by someone else. PROTECT YOUR IDEAS In order to protect your ideas and still get the client, you have to change how you deliver your concepts and specifically what you present.
4). The Sales Training Series: Dealing With Sales Objections and Stalls By : Duane Sparks Most salespeople think of “stalls” and “objections” as synonyms. Wrong. Stalls and objections are both things you may hear after you have asked for commitment, but an objection is a specific reason not to buy. In a stall—“I need to think about it”—the customer offers no particular reason for hesitating.
5). What’s the Objective of Your 1st Sales Appointment? By : Jeff Hardesty Have you defined what you want to happen at the conclusion of your 1st appointment? Only then can you actually set up a proficient sales methodology to achieve the defined objective more times than not. And with a pre-defined objective to your 1st appointment you can (1) set a realistic benchmark of success and (2) measure the outcome. It becomes part of your sales performance scorecard.
6). Stop Cold Calling and Double Your Sales in 30 Days By : Hartley Pinn Everyone knows what “cold calling” is, but how about “warm calling”? That’s easy, warm calling involves contacting your former clients and people you have already identified as prospects. These are the people you had made previous contact with and are listed in your database or on your Rolodex. If appropriate for your industry, I recommend spending one hour a day calling your database.
7). Restaurant Supply a Lifesaver for Caterer By : Kingston Amadan A few years ago, I was working as a catering manager of a local historic hotel. The hotel had been in terrible condition for many years until a group of investors purchased it and began the long arduous process of renovation. They were able to get the majority of it renovated before the funding started to run out, at which time they opened for business to offset some of the costs of ownership.
8). Employers Keep Screening Out Great Sales Candidates By : Robert Cameron Companies hiring sales reps stick to the same old hiring practices, and hire low performers that turn over, while screening out some of the best candidates. Robert Cameron examines two hiring myths and shows you how to easily select sales people who can sell.
9). The Five Cardinal Sins Salespeople Commit By : Bill Brooks We have very candid conversations with the sales professionals who come to our seminars and through those discussions we’ve discovered five critical errors that most salespeople make. Of course, we help them correct those mistakes, but it’s somewhat surprising as to how common they are. Here are the mistakes, see if you commit them in your own sales career.
10). The Downlow on Buying and Selling Concert Tickets Online By : Jared Lock Buying concert tickets online isn’t scary. In fact, it’s as easy as visiting Google and typing in the event you are looking for and follow with the word “tickets”. However, a couple of questions may come to mind when browsing for sports or concert tickets. 1. Why are tickets so expensive on the internet? On Ticketmaster the tickets are so much cheaper.

New Sales Articles
1). How To Get Return Customers By : David Gass Explains to to build customer loyalty and get customers to come back and buy more.
2). 7 Strategies for Loan Officers to Guarantee an Awesome 2006 By : Joe Pahl With the coming high interest rate market, loan officers who follow these seven strategies will guarantee having a successful 2006. The stratgies include new technology, proper planning, business referral groups, and maximizing your "geese that lays golden eggs" among others.
3). 7 Reasons Why Loan Officers SHOULD NOT Market to REALTORS By : Joe Pahl This article expresses why marketing to real estate agents is not always the best option and explores seven other ways to generate purchase business.
4). Staying Warm in a Cooling Market By : Bob Corcoran As the National Real Estate market changes there are five key items an agent can embrace to make the most of this market shift
5). Dealing with the RIGHT Decision Maker By : Tim Hagen Dealing with different decision making styles and decision makers appropriately is a big part of being successful in sales. This article will provide background to the different types of personalities that can be encountered in the sales process.
6). Get Ahead By Using Affiliates By : David Gass Describes what affiliates are and how to benefit from them.
7). How to Make an Unsuccessful Sale a Good Learning Experience By : Tim Hagen Losing a deal can be difficult, however learning from the experience can reap huge rewards. Successfully using what you did incorrectly can change future outcomes if addressed correctly.
8). Closing A Sale: Promise and Deliver! By : Hartley Pinn One of the chief complaints from customers about the way business is conducted these days centers on customer service. Either the service aspect is completely lacking or what has been promised to the customer hasn’t been kept. Dealing with the latter category, it is easy to see why customers are disappointed: sales people routinely over promise and then fail to deliver.
9). Sales Secrets for Entrepreneurs: Increase Profits in 12 Months Flat Through Consumer Education Programs! By : Chet Holmes You can attract far more prospects to look at your offer by providing an education than you'll ever get by simply offering your products or services. For example: Let's say you sell telephone systems, like Company X. Before discovering this concept, Company X would call hundreds of companies per day and ask if they were interested in talking about a new telephone system (product offer).
10). Sell Services Online By : Eggbilly Is it possible to take a normal offline service business like a legal practice, private medical practitioner or even a real estate business and make money with it from the Internet? As someone who’s been doing this since 1996, I say the answer is a resounding “YES”. If you are a business owner, or even an affiliate marketer, you know how hard it is to make a living online.